Lexis 200 wide

Raise £5 for charity in 15 minutes.

Complete this short survey and LexisNexis will donate £5 to the International Rescue Committee. We want to find out more about the daily challenges you face when drafting and reviewing legal documents.

The weblink to the survey is: https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/HMSP8QF

Tribunal dismisses bid to get board minutes for South West One via FOI PDF Print E-mail
Wednesday, 10 October 2012 12:34

The First-Tier Tribunal (Information Rights) has dismissed a bid to obtain the board minutes of the high-profile South West One joint venture through a freedom of information request.

South West One is owned by IBM (75%) and three public authorities (25%) – Somerset County Council, Taunton Deane Borough Council and Avon and Somerset Police Authority.

In Orr v The Information Commissioner and Avon and Somerset Police Authority EA/2012/0077, Mr Orr requested copies of South West One board minutes held by the police authority from April 2010 to the end of March 2011. There were four sets of board minutes covered by that period.

The police authority refused the request, relying on s. 41 of the Freedom of Information Act on the basis that the minutes had been received from the joint venture in confidence. It maintained that stance following a review.

The Information Commissioner’s Office upheld that refusal, saying the requirements of s. 41 had been satisfied. The ICO also concluded that there was no evidence that the joint venture agreement between IBM and the three public authorities and the service delivery contract between the police authority and South West One were being used to circumvent FOIA improperly.

Orr appealed. His ground of appeal was initially that the ICO should have found that SW1 was a public authority to which FOIA applied. But the Tribunal said this was “wholly misconceived” and “doomed to fail”.

However, the Tribunal declined to strike out the appeal as it had not seen the information requested nor the evidence of the deputy chief executive officer of the police authority. It said it could not therefore property judge whether the information was confidential in nature or whether a powerful public interest might demand disclosure anyway.

In its ruling, the Tribunal said it was “undeniable” that the police authority received the requested information from a third party (South West One) and that it was imparted on expressly confidential terms.

The Tribunal added that the minutes, which it had read, contained references to commercial initiatives and perceived opportunities, “clearly confidential in nature, disclosure of which would have been detrimental to the commercial interests of South West One”. The minutes also recorded discussions on a range of matters affecting the running of the venture.

Orr said he would have been prepared to accept the excision of sensitive names. This approach was rejected by the Tribunal.

“Board minutes are, by their nature, confidential information,” it said. “They record disagreements and minority opinions. They should frankly describe the inner workings of the company, whenever significant issues are discussed. It is important in the shareholders’ interests, that board minutes fully reflect what has been transacted.”

The Tribunal said it was in no doubt that disclosure of the minutes would have been detrimental to South West One’s interests.

On the issue of the public interest, the Tribunal said: “We have regard, on the one hand, to what is already in the public domain and, on the other, to the undoubted importance of transparency in the operation of joint ventures, in so far as that is consistent with the proper commercial interests of the company thereby created, here SW1.

“If a joint venture company has been formed for the specific purpose of frustrating the duties of disclosure enacted in FOIA; if public funds are being needlessly squandered in a badly–managed business; if serious conflicts of interest are or may be distorting the company`s operations, then there may be a strong case for disclosing information which reveals such facts, on the ground that disclosure by the requested public authority (here ASPA) would not be actionable.”

However, the Tribunal said this was not the case here. “There is no improper attempt to hide information from a FOIA request. Whether or not the criticism of South West One`s performance is justified, whether or not improper conflicts of interest have been permitted, the minutes shed no light on such issues,” it said.

The Tribunal said it saw no legitimate public interest in disclosure of the minutes, and therefore upheld the ICO’s decision that the police authority could rely on s. 41.

The Tribunal went on to say: “It is perhaps worth observing that, whilst the use of a joint venture company may create a ‘democratic deficit’ as regards the availability of the s.41 exemption, the position is less clear, as regards s.43(2) [prejudice to commercial interests].

“If one or more public authorities decide to engage in a commercial venture, most probably but not inevitably, through a limited company of which it or they is/are shareholder(s), such a company is a public authority by virtue of s.6 of FOIA but, as such, entitled to invoke s.43(2) to protect its commercial interests in response to, for example, a request for disclosure of its minutes.

“A similar request to the public authority shareholder could likewise be met by reliance on s.43(2). So when commercial interests are at stake, the elector`s right to know may not be significantly greater where the venture company is owned solely by a public authority rather than by a combination of public authorities and private investors.”

Anya Proops of 11KBW was counsel for the police authority.

Last month it emerged that South West One was suing one of its founder authorities, Somerset County Council, in a row over payments for procurement savings. The authority rejected the claims and said it would make counter-claims where it felt it had suffered losses.

_________________________________________________________________

CPD courses from just £17.50 (+VAT)

 

LGTV_logo_final_350_pxl

 

Try before you buy - your first course is free!

Click here to see the full list of courses on Local Government Law.tv

Unlimited access to all content for just £199 + VAT. Click here for more details.

_________________________________________________________________

 

 

Latest News

July 31, 2014

Court hearing over Tower Hamlets election to go ahead after challenge fails

An election court will be convened in August to hear a petition over whether the London Borough of Tower Hamlets’ elected mayor should be unseated. Read more
July 31, 2014

Tribunal tells council to disclose criteria used for grading positions of employees

Bradford Metropolitan District Council has been told that it must disclose the criteria it uses to grade employees’ positions. Read more
July 29, 2014

ICO says 'big data' must operate within existing data protection laws

The Information Commissioner’s Office has warned that ‘big data’ – the analysis of massive datatsets – “can – and must – operate within data protection law”. Read more
July 28, 2014

London borough approves abolition of its regional planning committees

The London Borough of Redbridge agreed earlier this month to abolish regional planning committees. Read more
July 24, 2014

Community council rapped for failure to help non-Welsh speakers follow meetings

A community council in Wales has been criticised for failing to provide ways for English speakers to follow its proceedings and for unreasonably preventing a resident from attending its meetings. Read more
July 24, 2014

Leadership of borough council in North West pursue unitary status

Chorley Borough Council’s leadership wants to break away from Lancashire and become a unitary. Read more
July 23, 2014

Government intervention in Doncaster to end early after good progress made

Government intervention at Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council is to end almost a year early in recognition of progress made in tackling its problems. Read more

 

Features

Dialogue iStock 000009191235XSmall 146X219
July 31, 2014

Media strategy for local councils - beyond the parish notice board

Will the National Association of Local Councils' guidance to town and parish councillors not to talk to journalists without prior consent have a chilling effect on public life? Eleanor Hoggart, assistant practice director of Legal Services… Read more
Spotlight iStock 000003933485XSmall 146x219
July 24, 2014

Academies and FOI

In an academies case, the First-tier Tribunal has recently considered issues around freedom of information and the boundaries of public and private service provision. Robin Hopkins looks at the lessons to be learned. Read more
July 24, 2014

Data protection, compulsory audit and the NHS

Mandatory ICO data protection audits are likely to be introduced for the NHS by the end of the year. Claire Bentley, Emma Godding and Jane Bennett look at the background and the key issues. Read more
July 10, 2014

Council meetings – lights, cameras, action!

New regulations come into force at the end of this month, leaving local authorities with less than 28 days in which to prepare for their meetings being filmed, tweeted or blogged. Olwen Dutton explains the changes. Read more
June 26, 2014

Speaking up

The High Court ruled earlier this year in a case where a non-planning councillor spoke at a planning committee meeting. Mary Tate examines the ruling. Read more
June 12, 2014

Data protection and child protection

Christopher Knight examines a strike-out application made by a number of local authorities over claims that they held inaccurate and damaging information about the claimant. Read more

 

 

Knowledge Bank

May 18, 2012

Managing in a Political Environment

Author: Nicholas Dobson, Freeth Cartwright This paper outlines the changing role of the local government lawyer in the context of the legal, political and constitutional framework of local government. This paper looks at the legal powers that underpin the role of local authorities, including the…
April 19, 2012

General Power of Confidence – ‘A New Hope’?

Author: Nicholas Dobson, Freeth Cartwright The general power of competence has been designed to give councils the confidence to act, using the power as their primary tool, without needing to refer back to central government. The question is: will the new power deliver?
March 27, 2012

Predetermination and Bias - Can Careless Talk Still Cost Decisions?

Author: Nicholas Dobson, Freeth Cartwright Ministers entered government much exercised about the law surrounding predetermination. In the opinion of some, this was a conspiracy by local government lawyers to undermine the democratic process. And they were going to have none of it! The 2010…
March 15, 2012

Recent developments in freedom of information

Author: Anya Proops, 11KBW The body of jurisprudence relating to freedom of information has continued to develop apace over the last year. The exponential growth in appeals being heard by both the first-tier and upper tribunals has meant that practitioners are having to work ever harder to keep…

Older news and features

July 24, 2014

Academies and FOI

June 26, 2014

Speaking up

Click here for full section archive

Banner

Featured Jobs


CLICK HERE to search all current vacancies

Featured Courses & Events

50% off LGLtv subscriptions

Sign up for Courses and Events Updates

* indicates required

Services v2

Yellow pages iStock 000009762383XSmall cropTo access details of individual advertisers, please click on the relevant banner below.

To search all entries in the Local Government Lawyer Services Directory, please click here

 

 


 Shout_to_the_top_looking_left_iStock_000006002590XSmall_98x74 Latest Blog Posts

 

 


 

Ballot_iStock_000006080605XSmall_thumb

Snap Judgement

Will the SRA's decision to remove the 16 hour minimum training requirement...