Legal Assistants (Litigation and Planning)
Give councils power to tackle vexatious village green applications, urges LGA PDF Print E-mail
Monday, 19 December 2011 14:31

The Local Government Association has called for councils to be given more powers to deal with “malicious, vexatious and incomplete” claims for village green status.

In its response to a government consultation on village greens, the LGA said local authorities should be able to claim back costs in appropriate cases.

The association argued that a high proportion of the claims were “simply used as delaying tactics to prevent new affordable housing or much needed regeneration”.

The LGA cited a number of cases to support its claims, including:

  • St Austell, Cornwall: a site proposed for village green status included beach huts and a car park. An inspectors’ report concluded that neither the beach huts nor the car park fitted the criteria for a village green.
  • Poole: the council had received two village green applications in the past year. One had been rejected, while the other was ongoing. Poole Council had spent £75,000 on legal and staffing costs “with the potential for a further £30,000 should the remaining application go to judicial review.”

The LGA pointed out that the cost to those making the application was minimal.

It argued that people should instead have their say on development through the planning system. The scope to do this will be boosted by the government’s reforms, including the development of local plans, the Association added.

The LGA also publicly backed government plans to close a ‘loophole’ that means village green application can delay developments which have planning permission and have begun building work.

Cllr David Parsons, Chairman of the LGA Environment and Housing Board, said: "Councils are keen to protect genuine village greens and community land in their neighbourhoods. However, the idea that a beach hut or car park constitutes a village green is clearly ridiculous.

"The right balance needs to be reached between looking after genuine village greens and the provision of affordable housing, services and jobs which local areas badly need. Councils are reliable and can be trusted to perform this function effectively.”

Cllr Parsons claimed that “millions of pounds of taxpayer's money” was being spent by councils processing village green applications where the primary aim was to prevent development.


Latest News

April 09, 2014

County council scraps energy from waste contract at cost of £30m-plus

A county council is to terminate a £600m waste contract at a cost of more than £30m, blaming the “failure to secure satisfactory planning permission”. Read more
April 03, 2014

Campaigners rule out further appeal over redevelopment of football ground

Campaigners who sought to have the planning permission for the redevelopment of Bristol Rovers’ Memorial Ground quashed have ruled out taking the case to the Court of Appeal on costs grounds. Read more
April 01, 2014

London borough to use s. 106 agreements to tackle 'buy-to-leave' homes

A London borough is consulting on plans to use s. 106 agreements to tackle the issue of “buy-to-leave” homes. Read more
March 31, 2014

Campaigners net hearing over planning permission for QPR training ground

Campaigners seeking to challenge Ealing Council’s decision to grant Queen’s Park Rangers planning permission for the redevelopment of a sports ground and to give the club a 200-year lease have been granted an oral… Read more
March 27, 2014

Court backs decision to pay only 20% of £250k recommended by LGO

A district council has fended off a judicial review challenge to its decision to pay a complainant only 20% of a £250,000 sum recommended by the Local Government Ombudsman. Read more
March 26, 2014

Councils lose High Court battle with Mayor of London over affordable rents

A group of nine councils have lost a High Court challenge to the Mayor of London’s plan to allow ‘affordable’ rents in new housing to be set at 80% of the market rate. Read more



projects portrait1
April 16, 2014

Recent changes to the CIL regime: a summary

Jonathan Darby provides a summary of recent changes that affected the Community Infrastructure Levy. Read more
Planning iStock 000002733689Small 146x219
April 02, 2014

The Planning Court comes into being

Richard Harwood OBE QC analyses the introduction of a Planning Court this week and outlines the key changes. Read more
April 02, 2014

Are local authorities bound by Ombudsman recommendations?

A High Court judge recently ruled that a council's decision to pay a developer only 20% of the £250,000 recommended by the Local Government Ombudsman was lawful. Nicholas Dobson analyses the case. Read more
April 02, 2014

Retrospective validation, exceptional circumstances and the Whitley principle

The High Court recently upheld approvals for Cardiff’s Energy from Waste scheme. Simon Bird QC analyses the case. Read more
April 02, 2014

Further chinks in the armour of town and village green status

Polly Reynolds analyses the likely impact of a key Supreme Court ruling on rectification of the register of town and village greens. Read more
March 26, 2014

Demolition – under permitted development rights or planning permission?

A recent case involving one of the Essex districts (advised by Essex Legal Services) sparked questions about the primacy of planning permission against permitted development rights in relation to demolition. Jacqueline Millward and Matthew Fox… Read more
March 26, 2014

Application forms and lawful uses

The High Court recently considered whether a local planning authority had lawfully substituted - under s. 191(4) of the TCPA 1990 - a lawful use of another description for that claimed in the application form. Peter Wadsley considers the case. Read more


Older news and features

March 05, 2014

Core stability

March 05, 2014

The sound and the fury

February 26, 2014

Applying the sequential test

February 13, 2014

Action stations

January 16, 2014

Bearing witness

January 16, 2014

Hunston upheld

January 09, 2014

Restrictions at retail parks

Click here for full section archive

Now Previewing on Green Belt Development - The Legal Issues (Click on bottom right of screen for full size.)

Featured Jobs

Ashford Borough Council Planning Lawyer
East Sussex Solicitor Planning and Highways

CLICK HERE to search all current vacancies

Featured Courses & Events

Sign up for Courses and Events Updates

* indicates required

Services v2

Yellow pages iStock 000009762383XSmall cropTo access details of individual advertisers, please click on the relevant banner below.

To search all entries in the Local Government Lawyer Services Directory, please click here


Easton Bevins Chartered Surveyors
Ivy Legal


 Shout_to_the_top_looking_left_iStock_000006002590XSmall_98x74 Latest Blog Posts





Snap Judgement

Is the role of monitoring officer worth the risk?