Local Government Lawyer

Government Legal Department Senior Roles

The High Court recently ruled that information withheld from a child’s parents in Forced Marriage Protection Order (FMPO) proceedings should also be withheld for a short period from the parents in the context of care proceedings. Megan Bithel-Vaughan analyses the ruling.

The case of London Borough of Enfield v The Mother & Ors [2026] EWHC 2473 (Fam) addresses the interplay between a Forced Marriage Protection Order (FMPO) application and subsequent care proceedings which arise from the same and/or similar facts. Specifically, the case considers withholding disclosure, which has already been withheld for the purposes of the Forced Marriage Protection Order application and whether it is appropriate to continue to withhold that disclosure in the subsequent public law proceedings.

There are limited facts available in the judgment, as the Judge also produced an accompanying “CLOSED” judgment where the Judge applied the law, as set out in the OPEN judgment to the facts of the case. It is therefore not necessary to set out the facts, limited as they were, in this article, instead this article focusses on the legal framework which the Court set out for application in future cases.

  • The Court confirmed that the Family Procedure Rules do not prevent continued non-disclosure. It is accurate to say that FPR 11.7(2) expressly permits the Court in FMPO proceedings to withhold submissions or evidence to protect the subject of the proceedings or any other person, or for any other good reason.  Further, it is accurate to say that Part 11 does not apply to care proceedings, which are governed by FPR Part 12, which contains no equivalent provision. However, the Court held that the applicable rule which allows the Court to permit continued withholding of submissions and/or evidence is the general case management power in FPR 12.12.(2)(a).
  • The Court confirmed that the principles as set out in Re T (Children: Non-Disclosure) [2024] EWCA Civ 241 apply.  To remind, the factors which should be considered are as follows:
    • The relevance of the material to the issues in the case.
    • Whether disclosure would involve a real possibility of significant harm and if so, what is the probability and nature of this harm.
    • Whether there are any measures which can sufficiently reduce the probability or impact of any harm.
    • Taking into account the importance of the material to the proceedings, what are the overall welfare advantages and disadvantages of disclosure and non-disclosure.
    • Whether the child’s interests so compellingly outweigh the rights of the party deprived of disclosure that any non-disclosure is strictly necessary, giving proper weight to the consequences for that party in the particular circumstances.
    • If non-disclosure is appropriate, can it be limited in scope or duration so that the interference with the rights of those to whom the disclosure is not granted and the administration of justice is not disproportionate to the feared harm.
  • Further, the Court reiterated that in cases concerning Forced Marriage, the particular context of Forced Marriage is a factor of particular weight that will need to be considered when considering the risk of harm, in particular the seriousness of the harm caused by forced marriage, which is “a fundamental abuse of human rights”.
  • The Court also considered the need to appoint, and did appoint, a special advocate, endorsing the case of Sheffield City Council v M [2022] EWHC 128 (Fam). 

The Court therefore, applied the factors in Re T, including those factors concerning the harm which is inherent to forced marriage. Again, whilst we cannot report on the specific reasoning, due to the facts being in a closed judgment, the Court concluded that whilst the withheld information was relevant to the care proceedings, immediate disclosure would involve a real possibility of significant harm being caused to an identified individual. Further, there were no sufficient mitigatory measures which could be put in place to allow for disclosure. The Court concluded that the interest in preventing harm so compellingly outweighed the parents’ rights that the information should continue to be withheld for a further period. However, the Court also endorsed the Local Authority’s plan which did include eventual and controlled disclosure, highlighting the importance that any interference was proportionate.

Megan Bithel-Vaughan is a barrister at Deka Chambers. Tim Parker KC of Deka Chambers acted for the mother.

Sponsored articles

LGL Red line

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Newsletter signup