Council to introduce s19 written policy after allowing “drift and delay” in management of case where child was not in full-time education
- Details
Derbyshire County Council has been criticised by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman after allowing “drift and delay” in its management of a child’s case when he was not in full-time education.
Following the Ombudsman’s investigation, the council has agreed to introduce a written policy explaining how it will carry out its duty under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 to provide education to children missing full-time education.
The woman behind the complaint, Miss B, complained that the council failed to ensure her son, C, received a suitable education after he began secondary school in September 2022.
C has special educational needs and struggled to access education despite having an Education, Health and Care (EHC) Plan.
Miss B said the council failed to update his plan often enough and his absence from education increased his distress and isolation.
Miss B told the Ombudsman that this increased the pressure she was under in caring for C and caused her isolation and exhaustion.
C had entered the secondary phase of his education in September 2022, attending a mainstream secondary school.
His needs meant he struggled to attend school full-time and by April 2023, his school considered it could no longer support him.
The council went on to issue him with an EHC Plan which continued to name a mainstream school.
Miss B did not agree with the contents of the Plan, including the named school and appealed to the Tribunal in October 2023.
In January 2024, the council accepted C could not attend a mainstream school. The council agreed to provide C with tuition at home.
The council entered a contract with a provider for “up to 15 hours a week” of tuition. However, Miss B said his tuition was only around one hour a week.
Simultaneously, the council considered whether C needed a specialist school placement. It agreed this in March 2024. It then agreed a consent order with Miss B, which ended her appeal.
The council issued a new ECH Plan for C which named a specialist school (School X).
The EHC Plan said School X would arrange for C to have an “individual learning and support programme” that it would review at least once a term.
The Plan said C would need “slow transition” to School X and that he needed an “enhanced transition and transition plan”. This envisaged a “reduced timetable with a gradual increase in attendance”.
The Ombudsman noted: “The council’s records contain no record of further contact with School X before December 2024, when the school provided a report on C’s progress. This said C was having more interaction with a key member of staff and that he took part in “short sessions” of teaching at home. But the report explained C had yet to attend the school building.”
In February 2025, Miss B made a complaint to the council.
In March 2025, School X provided another quarterly report. It referred to C having improved engagement with learning, but explained he still only received teaching at home. It recorded his attendance around 25%.
In May 2025, a review of C’s EHC Plan took place. Miss B made comments before the review, wanting changes to C’s Plan. This included specifying that C should receive between six and ten hours a week home tuition, with provision to increase this over time.
In June 2025, Miss B contacted the Ombudsman because while the council had acknowledged receipt of her complaint, it had not answered it.
In August 2025, the council issued a draft amended Plan that contained modest changes to Section F of the Plan, specifying C’s education provision.
In October 2025, the council issued a final Plan for C, containing only those changes it proposed in August.
Considering the complaint, the Ombudsman noted that Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 says a council must arrange suitable alternative educational provision when it finds that a child cannot attend school because of:
- a permanent exclusion;
- an illness; or
- for any other reason making the school inaccessible to the child.
The Ombudsman found fault in the council’s management of C’s case throughout the time under investigation (January 2024 to October 2025).
Specifically, the investigation found:
- there was no evidence the council checked the home tuition arranged for C in January 2024, before it agreed a place for him at School X from March 2024;
- there was no evidence the council checked the provision C received from School X, nor asked for any updates, before December 2024. This despite C’s Plan recognising he could not resume education full-time;
- there was no record the council made any more checks with School X after December 2024. This despite the evidence provided then which showed C remained on a heavily reduced part-time timetable and only received education at home. It made no enquiries to find out what plan was in place to try and increase his exposure to education, nor what barriers prevented that. It made no attempt to arrange an earlier review of C’s EHC Plan despite knowing these facts;
- it had failed to ensure a review of C’s EHC Plan took place within 12 months of the previous review, held in 2023.
The Ombudsman said: “Our guidance explains councils should have policies and procedures to review cases where pupils are on a part-time timetable, or otherwise struggle to attend school, over a prolonged time. The lack of a clear policy here was therefore a fault. I considered it may have contributed to why it took so long for the council to review C’s Plan after he became enrolled at School X.
“There was also fault after the council began its review of C’s EHC Plan in May 2025. It failed to confirm within four weeks its intent to amend the Plan and provide a copy of the proposed amendments to Miss B. And it took more than 12 weeks from the date of the review meeting to issue C with an amended Plan, delaying over 10 weeks in total.”
The Ombudsman continued: “There was also fault when Miss B complained, drawing attention to the Council’s delays. It failed to provide a reply to her complaint at stage one of its corporate complaint policy. It was not until Miss B contacted this office, four months after her complaint to the council, that it provided a reply at stage two.
“In its reply, the council recognised delay in answering Miss B’s complaint and arranging C’s review held in May 2025. It apologised and offered a symbolic payment, which was good practice.
“However, I did not consider these measures went far enough to remedy the injustice caused to Miss B and C.”
To remedy the injustice caused, the council was recommended to:
- Apologise to Miss B;
- Make a symbolic payment to Miss B of £1,000;
- Commit to agreeing to introduce a Section 19 policy and provide the Ombudsman with a timescale for when this will be completed of no more than six months;
- Commit that when writing the policy it will take account of Ombudsman guidance on this subject;
- Commit to ensuring it makes all relevant officers aware of the policy once complete and tells the Ombudsman how it will do that and by when.
Derbyshire County Council has been approached for comment.
Lottie Winson
Sponsored articles
How hair strand testing should be instructed for family court proceedings
How Finders International Supports Council Officers
CaseLaw Tracker
Lawyer
Paralegal: Education and SEN
Solicitor or Barrister: Education and SEN
Locums




