Local Government Lawyer

 

A committee of MPs and peers has set out a series of principles it says Government departments should observe when drafting preambles to statutory instruments.

In a report, Preambles to statutory instruments: the little things that matter, the Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments (SIs) said problems with the evidence provided about the laws enabling SIs were “a recurring issue hindering effective parliamentary scrutiny”.

The committee urged Government departments to ensure they identify all laws and preconditions that enable the making of a statutory instrument, citing this evidence as a ‘requirement of the rule of law’.

The MPs and peers warned that failure to do so would raise doubts over the instrument's legality.

Committee Chair Sir Bernard Jenkin said: “We often have to raise issues with Government departments regarding the evidence they provide about the powers they are relying on. The Committee’s main job is ensuring that Government stays within the powers Parliament has given – this is infinitely harder if that evidence is not forthcoming.

“The Committee is not being pedantic about this. Finances are tight, and time is finite. The time wasted by departments in revoking and redrafting legislation could be better spent elsewhere, and we are also conscious that companies need certainty rather than a statute book that is constantly chopping and changing.

“We know departments work hard to get things right and the Committee has a good working relationship with Government. Our report is a chance to take stock of this difficult area of law and improve working practices in the future.”

The Joint Committee for Statutory Instruments is a bicameral committee established to check the legal and technical quality of secondary legislation – or statutory instruments – under powers granted to the Government by Acts of Parliament.

Directory

Newsletter signup