Pilot scheme launched for greater transparency in Court of Protection

A pilot scheme allowing the public and the media access to Court of Protection hearings in England and Wales has been launched.

The scheme will apply – via a Pilot Practice Direction – to new proceedings issued as of last Friday (29 January). Hearings scheduled already under the old rules will not be changed but some urgent open hearings will feed through to the courts from next month.

The Practice Direction will effectively change the default position “to one where hearings are held in public with reporting restrictions to protect identities”, the Courts and Tribunals Judiciary said.

“This means that when an order has been made under the pilot, both the media and the public will be able to attend, unless a further order has been made which excludes them. This will also apply to proceedings issued pre-29 January but where a further hearing becomes necessary after the start date.”

Her Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) will also amend the way in which court lists are displayed, so that they provide a short descriptor of what the case is about. This is intended to allow the media and members of the public to make an informed decision on whether to attend the hearing. Lists will be published on a weekly basis in court buildings and online at www.courtserve.net.

Sir James Munby (pictured), President of the Court of Protection, said: “For the last six years accredited media have been able to attend Family Court cases and have been better informed about the work of the Family Court as a result. It is logical to look at extending this greater transparency to the Court of Protection, provided the right balance can be struck to safeguard the privacy of people who lack capacity to make their own decisions.”

Mr Justice Charles, Vice President of the Court of Protection, added: “I have long supported this move towards more public hearings to promote a wider understanding of the work and approach of the Court of Protection and improve its performance and that of those who appear in it.

“I am aware that others hold different views on whether hearings should generally be in public and hope that the pilot will provide useful evidence to weigh the rival arguments.”

Justice Minister Caroline Dinenage said: “It is our ambition to increase the transparency and public accountability of our courts. While the privacy of the people involved will continue to be protected, it is also important that the public and media are able to see how justice is done.”

The Judiciary said the pilot was expected to run in all regions for at least six months (with the possibility of extension) to allow for the changes to be fully tested.

In an advisory role Ministry of Justice Analytical Services will seek to understand how the pilot has been implemented and how it has worked in practice, exploring issues such as accommodating press and the public in courtrooms, and any publication or unwanted disruption attributed to the changes.

More information on the pilot can be found here.