Local Government Lawyer

 

A motion calling for an NHS Trust to be given preferential treatment in the bidding process for Worcestershire County Council’s old headquarters has been withdrawn, following advice from the monitoring officer warning that debating the motion could be seen as biased.

Hazel Best told members on Friday that a motion tabled by Reform UK group members could prejudice the integrity of the marketing process, which is currently underway.

Worcestershire launched the marketing process to sell its 16.6-acre former County Hall in October.

The site neighbours Worcestershire Royal Hospital, which has bid to purchase the property.

Reform UK group members tabled a motion to be discussed on Thursday calling for the local authority to agree that its preferred option is for the hospital to take ownership of the site.

The motion said: “This Council notes that Worcestershire Royal Hospital is operating well beyond its capacity and is likely to do so for the foreseeable future; and that the adjacent Worcestershire County Council is about to have a vacant site following the demolition of County Hall, likely by early 2027.

"This Council agrees that its preferred option for the vacant site’s usage is for the development of the Hospital or related NHS usage, on all or part of the vacant site."

The motion said the council should instruct officers to meet with representatives from the NHS as soon as possible to establish what plans, intentions, or requests the NHS has with regard to the usage of the vacant site.

Speaking during the meeting, monitoring officer Hazel Best said it would not be appropriate for council to debate the motion whilst County Hall is being actively marketed.

She said: "As with any disposal of a public asset, the council has a duty to secure best consideration for taxpayers and to show that the process is conducted fairly, transparently and in a way that delivers the best outcome for the county.

"Any debate on a particular proposal by a particular purchaser could be seen to be biased and not following a due process.

"So debating a motion which seeks to direct discussion or give apparent preference to a particular prospective purchaser could be perceived as prejudicing the integrity of that process - and on that basis as the monitoring officer I'm not agreeing to this motion continuing to be debated and on the agenda for this meeting."

A FAQ published by the council detailing the local authority's answer to questions as to why the site was not offered to the NHS says:  "The site is being marketed openly. The marketing process allows interested parties to come forward with proposals.

“The planning advice obtained for the site identifies residential development as acceptable in principle but also notes there may be potential for other uses, including healthcare and specialist accommodation, subject to planning and site constraints."

The bidding closed on 12 November. The council has yet to make a decision on the successful bid.

Adam Carey

Directory

Newsletter signup