There is no power to make an order permitting landlord to force entry into home of tenant to enforce contractual right of access, district judge maintains
- Details
A district judge has called for a higher court to decide whether it is possible to for a judge to authorise forced entry into a tenant’s home by a landlord, after citing cases dating from the 17th century to suggest it is not.
District Judge Cridge, sitting in Bromley County Court, said there had been contradictory decisions in county courts on this but his view was that the law did not allow a court to authorise forced entry and so this could not be permitted simply by the terms of a tenancy agreement.
He heard a case brought by Phoenix Community Housing Association (Bellingham & Downham) against tenant Ms Winch.
Ms Winch had complained of damp and mould throughout her flat. But when Phoenix sent staff to inspect this she refused to admit them.
Phoenix secured an injunction requiring her to let workers into her flat and further asked permission to break in if she still refused to admit them.
DJ Cridge warned Ms Winch she might face a fine or imprisonment for contempt of court if she persisted in refusing to let workers in, and that Phoenix could start eviction proceedings.
He said other judges had reached different conclusions on the question of forced entry into the home.
“It needs to be decided by a higher court,” he said, noting that in September 2026 he transferred a number of such claims to the High Court.
Explaining his reasoning on why he lacked power to grant forced entry, DJ Cridge said: “For more than four centuries, the courts and Parliament have taken a consistent approach to entry into the home. Since Semayne's Case in 1604, the common law has held that in civil matters the sheriff, executing the court's own process, ‘may enter to execute civil process: but he may not break in’.”
He noted that when senior courts have made even their most intrusive orders, “they have deliberately stopped short of authorising entry by force”.
Parliament has made it an offence to use violence to enter premises against the occupier's will, unless there is lawful authority.
DJ Cridge said: “An order permitting a landlord to break into their tenant's home would go further than anything those authorities recognise. It would go beyond a search order…which requires the occupier's permission to enter. It would give a landlord the very authority to enter by force that Parliament has withheld, in circumstances where Parliament has required landlords to come to court rather than help themselves."
Concluding, the district judge said: "The court has no power to make an order permitting a landlord to force entry into their tenant's home to enforce an express or implied contractual right of access. I have considered with care the judgments in Hammond, Stonewater and Bromford and the approved note of the decision in Taylor Clark. With great respect, they do not persuade me that the court does have that power."
He added: "The common law has long protected the home against forced entry. Parliament has permitted it only by express words. Even when the senior courts have made their most intrusive orders, they have stopped short of authorising the use of force to cross the threshold. An order that the occupier must permit entry is enforced against the occupier, not by breaking in."
Nor do the Civil Procedure Rules supply that power, DJ Cridge found.
He said a contractual right to force entry, however it is worded, “does not assist the claimant. I doubt that a landlord can, by a term of the tenancy, give themselves a right to force entry into the tenant's home. But even if they can, the court has no power to make an order permitting them to do so. A tenancy agreement cannot confer on the court a power the law has not given it”.
Mark Smulian
See also: Solicitors Mollie McQuade and Chelsea Wilson-Flynn of law firm Anthony Collins have provided a table of recent county court decisions on forced entry.




