Local Government Lawyer

Government Legal Department Senior Roles

Planning authorities have no discretion to extend time for the validation of reserved matters applications and a Planning Inspectorate case officer can determine validation without intervention by a qualified inspector.

Those two rulings by the Planning Court have come from CMG Ockelton, sitting as a judge of the High Court, in a case that turned on which day an application was submitted when received after working hours.

Developer TNC Group Holdings brought the case against the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government.

It had applied to Wealden District Council to demolish a care home and build another, and an application for reserved matters was required within 18 months after the grant of permission, which expired on 4 March 2025.

TNC that day used the Planning Portal to make the application. It was not received or seen by the council until the afternoon of 5 March, and Wealden later decided the application was out of time so the permission had lapsed.

The developer appealed to the Planning Inspectorate under s 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 claiming Wealden failed to determine the application in time. But an inspectorate case officer rejected it as out of time.

Mr Ockelton explained the sequence involved. He said TNC applied through the Planning Portal at 4.36 pm on 4 March. At 5.05 pm the portal accepted the payment online but did not process this until 9.06 am on 5 March and at 3.16 pm that day it submitted the application to the council, which downloaded it automatically into its system at 3.46 pm. Thus it became a day late.

“There is no scope for the retrospective extension of time by the council, and if the application is not made within the terms of the permission it follows that the development conditionally permitted cannot take place because the condition cannot now be fulfilled,” Mr Ockelton said.

TNC argued that the portal is the council’s agent, such that submission to it is the same as submission to Wealden.

Mr Ockelton called this point “hopeless”as the portal stated that once an application has been made “‘it will automatically be received by the relevant local planning authority”.

He explained the portal is a mode of transmission and “nobody would think that for these purposes the [portal] was itself acting as the local planning authority for the purposes of receipt”.

Wealden clearly stated that after 5pm was outside its business hours and the application was thus made on 5 March and so was out of time.

Turning to who has power to ‘triage’ planning appeals, Mr Ockelton said that while appeals must be determined by inspectors, “the administration and triage of planning appeals, including the rejection of invalid appeals, is not reserved to inspectors…it is not a matter in which any question of planning judgment arises, and the special training of inspectors is not required”.

Jack Smyth of No5 Barristers Chambers, who represented the Secretary of State. commented: “This brings clarity to an area which has been uncertain for a long time.

“The take-away from this case is that developers must submit their RMAs on time. Even a very modest delay, even of a day, will be fatal to the validation of such an application.”

He said the judgment meant local planning authorities and the inspectorate were “likely to take a firm position in declining to validate applications which are not made in time”.

Mark Smulian

Sponsored articles

LGL Red line

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Directory

Newsletter signup