Family Justice Council consults on draft guidance on use of hair strand testing
- Details
The Family Justice Council (FJC) has launched a consultation on draft Guidance on the Use of Hair Strand Testing within Family Proceedings.
The FJC said the draft had been developed by its Hair Strand Testing Working Group and is intended to assist judges, legal practitioners and advocates involved in family proceedings where hair strand testing is undertaken.
The introduction to the draft guidance says: “Hair strand testing is widely used within family proceedings to gather evidence when there are concerns that the use of alcohol or substances by caregivers poses a risk to children. Whilst the toxicological methods used to detect substances in hair are scientifically robust there are a number of variables which affect the interpretation of the results. In recent years, there has been growing concern regarding an over-reliance on hair strand evidence within family proceedings.
“This guidance does not seek to undermine the underlying science in hair strand testing. For well over a decade, the High Court and the Court of Appeal have consistently stated that the science of hair-strand testing ‘is now well-established and not controversial’. Rather, there is a real need ‘to treat numerical data with proper caution’. As has been said by Hayden J, while the science itself may be well established, the ‘interpretation of the testing may not always be free from controversy’.”
According to the draft, the guidance aims to “provide an overview of the factors which impact upon hair strand testing and interpretation; guidance on best practice when instructing a testing provider and on the interpretation of hair strand test results; and consideration of how hair strand testing sits within the wider context of decision-making for children and families.”
The FJC said it would welcome comments from all interested parties, including members of the judiciary, legal practitioners, social workers, children’s guardians, laboratory professionals, expert witnesses, academics, representative bodies, and those with lived experience in the family justice system.
The consultation will remain open until 7 December.
Sponsored articles
How Finders International Supports Council Officers
How hair strand testing should be instructed for family court proceedings
Solicitor or Barrister: Education and SEN
Lawyer
Paralegal: Education and SEN
Locums




