Distinct legal system for Wales 'inevitable', says Counsel General

The increasing volume of Welsh-only laws mean that the creation of a distinct legal jurisdiction for Wales is inevitable, the Counsel General for Wales has claimed.

In a keynote speech at the Legal Wales Conference in Bangor University last week, Mick Antoniw said: “Now that we have two legislatures it goes without saying that we should have two jurisdictions. It concerns me greatly that, somehow, the concept of the England and Wales jurisdiction has taken on a sort of mythical and philosophical aura. I take the view that the creation of distinct jurisdiction is a modest and sensible transitional way forward until there is such a body of Welsh or English law that the move to separate jurisdictions becomes inevitable.”

The Counsel General told the conference that the Welsh Government had already set out a vision of what a distinct jurisdiction could look like but in the meantime they had to make a single jurisdiction work.

“To this end we are taking steps to ensure so far as possible that neither the single jurisdiction nor divergence in Welsh laws result in detriment to the people of Wales, or to Wales’s post-EU future. And we know that members of the legal community too are playing their part. We welcome this; we encourage it; we want to see more of it,” Antoniw said.

He argued that the creation of a distinct legal jurisdiction would be an opportunity to develop a Welsh solution to counter a raft of UK Government reforms – legal aid cuts, court closures and increased court fees – which he claimed were reducing access to justice.

Antoniw said: “Legal aid is not devolved, we do not have the funding to restore the cuts in legal aid, but we can start to look at doing things differently. We have to look how our tribunals operate, how we improve access to them; we have to look at the advice systems funded by the Welsh Government, pro bono systems, trade union legal support systems, and third sector support and advice organisations. There may be an opportunity here to be creative, draw different strands together and create an alternative model.”

The Counsel General said the legal profession had a key role to play in delivering his vision of a new legal system fit for a modern Wales.

He said: “I want the legal sector to engage with the Welsh Government as we work to deliver meaningful change for the better in Wales; the kind of change that grows a thriving business sector, a world-class education and research sector, and a globally envied justice system; a country in which every single individual stands a decent chance of making it if they work hard.”